Delta SkyMiles Makes Big Money Because of Costco, and It Won’t Last

Thursday I wrote about Delta CFO Paul Jacobson’s talk at the Bank of America Merrill Lynch 2017 Transportation Conference. Brian Sumers at Skift wrote about it Friday morning as well,

Delta argues recent changes to its frequent flyer program have helped improved loyalty, but not everyone is so sure. What they almost certainly have done, however, is improve profitability.

I don’t think this is true at all.

Delta is more profitable, the biggest driver is lower fuel prices. Secondarily Delta earns a revenue premium over its competitors but says that isn’t because of its frequent flyer program. People spend more to fly Delta because of its reputation for reliability, not because of SkyMiles.

SkyMiles is also more profitable, but that is not because of changes they’ve made to the program. It’s because of their record-setting deal with American Express. They got an early renewal at a higher price point that we’ve seen before from co-brand deals because American Express lost Costco and Delta was their second biggest co-brand card, Amex wasn’t going to risk losing it too. They were willing to overpay to lock it down.

Sumers explains Jacobsen’s logic saying that they’re awarding the right number of miles for flights so they can really invest in the value of those miles.

It was an obvious decision for Delta, Jacobsen said, because it keeps the airline from awarding too many miles to customers who fly long distances but do not create much revenue for the airline. Now, he said, Delta is less worried about how customers redeem miles, because travelers who have earned them are valuable for the company.

He’s suggesting that Delta miles have become more valuable, which is preposterous. Sumers exposes the whopper that this is.

In an April post, Gary Leff of ViewFromTheWing, wrote that “Delta devalues more often than Argentina” after he said it “massively” increased the cost of any awards on its partner airlines.

“The biggest problem SkyMiles faces is their trust deficit,” Leff wrote. “You don’t get information to understand what miles are worth, and when they make changes Delta doesn’t play straight with what they’re doing with your miles or how that will affect you.”

He’s not the only blogger with this opinion. Ben Schlappig, who writes OneMileataTime, wrote a similar post the same week.

“What a crappy thing for Delta to do,” he said. “They’ve had award price increase after award price increase, but this is the most drastic one yet, as it seems to impact the cost of travel on all partner airlines.”

Bloggers have also criticized Delta for pushing customers to make redemptions for items other than airfare, like champagne in a lounge, or upgrades to premium economy. But they argue customers receive far less value if they redeem for anything except airfare. A bottle of Dom Perignon in the lounge might be free for a frequent flyer, they say, but because Delta sets the prices in miles, it’s rarely a good deal.

“They are trying to create the perfect company town,” Leff said. “They pay out SkyMiles, and then set the prices of goods in their company-owned store. And here’s the thing, they have a monopoly in this town.”

More fundamentally, Delta is awarding fewer miles for flying and more miles for credit card spend. The redemption value of a mile isn’t tied to the revenue a customer generates flying Delta. The redemption value of a mile is tied to what American Express is paying, minus the margin they’re trying to earn.

Jacobsen claims the program changes make SkyMiles more valuable to American Express. That’s historical revisionism in the extreme. American Express is paying Delta more because they lost the Costco deal, and when the New York Times asked Amex whether SkyMiles were worth more or worth less, they refused to answer.

However American Express is engaged in creative destruction, spending more marketing their own card products than ever before, in intense competition with Chase which is setting records spending on rewards as well.

Card revenue has been driving airline profits, but as airline programs have gotten worse bank programs have gotten better. Airlines are going to have to spend more to compete, eroding their better-than-50% margins on frequent flyer programs. Those high margins ultimately aren’t sustainable as competition heats up.

At the same time, big credit card revenue is contingent on maintaining high interchange rates which along with consumer interest fund rewards. Competition in the payments space, and new technologies, risk driving down those rates. (So does regulation, something that was more feared before Donald Trump was elected.)

There’s dual pressure on SkyMiles, and other airline frequent flyer program, profitability. There’s risk to the revenue model and more competition for customers. Things may start getting really hard for loyalty executives, and conditions could soon put the lie to claims that ‘more money from American Express means customers are happier.’

About Gary Leff

Gary Leff is one of the foremost experts in the field of miles, points, and frequent business travel - a topic he has covered since 2002. Co-founder of frequent flyer community InsideFlyer.com, emcee of the Freddie Awards, and named one of the "World's Top Travel Experts" by Conde' Nast Traveler (2010-Present) Gary has been a guest on most major news media, profiled in several top print publications, and published broadly on the topic of consumer loyalty. More About Gary »

More articles by Gary Leff »

Comments

  1. People give a lot of crap about DL with their unannounced redemption rate changes which I agree suck. However, as many people want to redeem their miles for J award tickets between the US and EU, it’s the best option in terms of availability at the lower rates especially for those based in the West Coast.

  2. The notion Skypesos are worth more is about as laughable as Drumpf draining the swamp by filling it with the Golden, er Goldman Sachs cronies. #tiredofwinning

  3. Based in SFO and never found reasonable redemptions using Skypesos. Always seems to require a shitty stopover rather than nonstop. Best redemption is via Turkish/Swiss IST/ZRH

  4. Delta’s behavior in all this is pretty repugnant. It would perhaps be a bit easier to take if they weren’t treating their customers like a pack of chumps.

  5. Alternate reality worked for trump.

    Delta’s suck up CEO hopes it will work for him too. And he’s probably right depending on how much stupid trump deplorables fly delta – which is a fair assumption since they’re based in an ignorant hillbilly state.

  6. @Mser — So Delta is bad for requiring a “shitty stopover,” but then the alternative is…stopping in VIE or IST and that’s so much better?

  7. I am making tons of sky miles from my delta Amex…. the benefit to me is in status, or metal as Gary calls it, which is a nice perk for me….. I don’t get as much out of my miles in terms of free trips but I do get a more premium flying experience which for me is the biggest driver. Just my two cents from somebody who is happy with the delta Amex. I recommend it to anybody who flies delta regularly….

  8. Hmm, I’m a stupid trump deplorable that lives in an ignorant hillbilly state. I always appreciate compliments from enlightened and tolerant people.

  9. The lefties always talk about tolerance are the most intolerant people there is, I guess they would rather of had the Murdering, Treasonous, lesbian lawyer in office. The go to instant anger when they cannot shove their socialist ideas down other peoples throats.

    Now to Delta, I have said it before and I will say it again, stop forcing people to lengthy layovers or multiple layovers to get from point A to B, without burning up all of the skypeso’s on one ticket vs getting tickets for a family of three.

    The big 3 Airlines are racing to the bottom just like the big 3 auto companies did and still are.

  10. I recently flew a two leg economy trip on United then Delta. United made me feel like cargo where Delta made me feel like I read flying first class. That’s how you get my loyalty. ( despite being a deplorable from a bright red hillbilly state )

  11. Delta Skymiles has become a less worthwhile proposition ( for consumers ) in the short while that I have been paying attention . The carrot keeps getting farther away . I dutifully flew Delta coach across the Pacific ten round trips all the while looking forward to my Skymiles Award ticket . By the time I had flown enough miles the cost had increased again . I finally gave in and applied for an American Express card , and another , and another . Of course the cost in miles has gone up again but , I was able to book a few award trips before the bonus miles were depleted .
    Now good friend Delta has eliminated a flight that I depended on : NRT – BKK . Once the shortest long journey among others that were even longer , now not even that advantage available .
    About 5,000 Skymiles in my account and I don’t plan on seeking more .
    Maybe some day market forces will convince Delta and other airlines to have more generous frequent flyer programs . I doubt that will be anytime soon . They are making too much money now . They just don’t need Skymiles to sell more tickets .
    I think it is the perceived promise betrayed that spurs my resentment . If there had never been a loyalty program offered then maybe I wouldn’t feel mistreated .
    For now : Cathay Pacific with Alaska miles seems like the best deal !

  12. You know, there are people that would gripe if they were hung with a new rope. Delta strives to have a competitive FF mileage program while improving customer service, and keeping planes on time. Atlanta is NOT a hillbilly city, and its customers are far from being DEPLORABLE.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *