Rental car companies don’t have nearly the fully developed loyalty programs that airlines and hotels do.

I keep expecting Avis to re-launch their program, but that keeps not happening.

Both Avis and Hertz have really good top status tiers, but you cannot earn those just based on rentals. Hertz sells theirs. Avis actually does too each year as part of the US Travel Associatoin/American Express Daily Getaways.

Hertz will status match. The top tier they offer based on rentals is Presidents Club and that only gets you a guaranteed one car class upgrade.

National status matches too, usually though only in conjunection with their annual “1-2-Free” promotion. But their top tier — Executive Elite — only lets you earn a free rental day marginally faster, and lets you pick most cars rather than just up to full size when redeeming free rental days.

For most business travelers I think that the sweet spot is National’s Executive status. You get that free with American Express Platinum, and it’s been a part of the Milepoint.com Premium membership package the last two years.

National’s program has for years let you pick any car from their Emerald Aisle as a basic member, and Executive members get to pick from the “Executive Aisle” which means incrementally better cars. I usually wind up with a Nissan, which I do prefer over say a Ford Taurus.

But I have Executive Elite status. My last two rentals have been free.

  • A 3-day rental using 1-2-Free rental days before they expired at the end of June. That was capped at full size.
  • A 3-day rental using free rental days. That was in Hawaii, and I picked a convertible.

I don’t think Executive Elite status is worth stretching for. But if you’re going to rent, then National makes sense for many. And if you’re going to wind up renting enough for that status, it’s nice to grab a convertible on Maui instead of just another sedan.


  1. Vince said,

    Did you have to negotiate for the convertible, or did the rep at National just give it to you as a complimentary upgrade?

  2. mark said,

    Just to clarify, if you have National’s top elite status, can you pick any car on the lot? I know there is an Emerald area and an Emerald Executive area. Is there an Emerald Executive Elite area? I get confused by National’s program because the elite statuses have similar names (it’s not like Silver, Gold, Platinum for airlines).

  3. Brian said,

    One of the better things with ‘normal’ free day at National is that they are good for one way rentals. With hertz there is a points premium involved.

  4. johnf said,

    For what its worth, if you have the AA world elite master card, or any other world elite mastercard, you get the National’s and Avis’s top status for free. Go to http://www.mastercard.us/travel/world-elite-summary.html?choice=car and then select the programs that you want to join.

    John

  5. mametester said,

    Enjoy the Andaz Maui!

  6. Gary Leff said,

    @John it’s not top status with either National or Avis but it is good status for sure!

  7. johnf said,

    @Gary Leff I thought Avis first and National Emerald Executive were their top statuses. Sorry for the misinformation!

  8. Gary Leff said,

    @johnf – no worries, a great reminder about world elite mastercard — i will feature your advice on that tomorrow. thank you!

  9. johnf said,

    @Gary Leff
    I’m glad my wrongness was of help…ha. Maybe you could post some info on the free flight upgrades that are offered through the program. I assume that one has to buy higher fare tickets, but is it worth it, or are there any sweet spots? I called the travel company the other day, to see if there were specific fare buckets that qualified for free upgrades, but the agent said it was different for every airline.

  10. Mark said,

    Was my question missed? :)

  11. stvr said,

    This isn’t hanging together. AFAIK, being a National elite doesn’t entitle you to anything more than a full size on free day rentals. Sounds like you got a little extra (blogger?) love.

  12. stvr said,

    I stand corrected. Just went over the Ts and Cs. You rent 25 times a year?!

  13. Rob P said,

    In addition to going through a portal and using a good CC, are there any more ways to maximize a National rental?

  14. iahphx said,

    If you’re willing to hunt through the many car rental discount codes/coupons, I think National provides the best value for customers in the entire travel industry. Good rates, excellent service, good cars and a decent rewards program (especially if you have occasional need for one-way rentals, which they include as their free days). In other words, pretty much 100% customer satisfaction. I can’t say that about anybody else in the travel industry.

  15. Gary Leff said,

    @Rob P – coupon codes, for instance Entertainment book 1 free day on a 3-day rental

  16. Rob P said,

    Thank you!

  17. Vince said,

    Gary, if you’d rather answer my question (see the first comment) by e-mail, that’s fine. I am genuinely curious to know the answer. Thanks.

  18. mark said,

    hello?

  19. Add A Comment

home | top

View from the Wing is a project of Miles and Points Consulting, LLC. This site is for entertainment purpose only. The owner of this site is not an investment advisor, financial planner, nor legal or tax professional and articles here are of an opinion and general nature and should not be relied upon for individual circumstances.

Advertiser Disclosure: Many (but not all) of the credit card offers on the site are from banks from which we receive compensation if you are approved. Compensation does not impact the placement of cards other than in banner advertising (we do not currently control the banner advertising on this blog). We don’t include all US credit card offers available on this site. Instead, I write primarily about cards which earn airline miles, hotel points, and some cash back (or have points that can be converted into the same).

Editorial Note: The opinions, analyses, and evaluations here are mine and not provided by any bank including (but not limited to) American Express, Chase, Citibank, US Bank, Barclaycard or any other company. They have not reviewed, approved or endorsed what I have to say.