Assuming that the merger between American and US Airways is actually consummated, we know that the combined entity will be called American Airlines and will be based the Dallas Fort Worth area. The frequent flyer program will be AAdvantage and the airline will be a part of the oneworld alliance (US Airways is currently a member of Star).

On the merger announcement day, Doug Parker explained that he learned a lesson when integrating US Airways with America West — it’s better to take the IT architecture of the bigger airline, rather than migrating the larger data set into the software platform of the smaller carrier. He thought that lesson was applied well when Delta and Northwest merged. And he was presumably too kind to say it, but the disastrous effects of ignoring that lesson played out in 2012 when United migrated to the old Continental SHARES system.

With US Airways miles becoming AAdvantage miles, and presumably retaining the AAdvantage computer program, we also likely get the AAdvantage award charts. There may be some modifications along the way, but we can expect to lose the character of the US Airways charts. And even if that weren’t true, we would be able to expect to see many of the unique values in the US Airways chart harmonized away (there are also some real disadvantages to their award rules and chart, but here I’m talking about the gems).

So I started to ponder what I’ll miss the most about the old US Airways Dividend Miles once it’s gone.

  1. US to North Asia for 90,000 miles in business class and 120,000 miles in first class.

  2. Enroute stopovers often won’t change the price of an award. Flying to North Asia (like Hong Kong or Beijing) is less expensive than flying to Europe even if you transit the Atlantic and make a Europe stopover on the way. It’s cheaper to fly US – Frankfurt (stop) – Hong Kong and visit both places than just to fly to Frankfurt.

  3. Seemingly contradictorily (although it’s not once you understand that awards don’t autoprice) often the first stopover city will determine an award price. If you stopover in Tokyo enroute to Singapore US Airways will often price an award as North Asia (Tokyo) rather than the more South Asia (Singapore).

  4. Domestic 3 cabin first class is the same price as 2-cabin first or business (50,000 miles). That’s great for flying United from New York to Los Angeles or San Francisco for instance, why fly business class on those routes when for no additional miles you can fly first? Of course United is removing three-cabin service there anyway, so maybe the merger is coming at the right time.

  5. Cheap Mileage Upgrades. US Airways mileage upgrades are based on flight distance starting at 5000 miles and $25, with the cash co-pay waived for elites on domestic routes. American charges more miles for most flights and hits up elites for co-pays on domestic flights (but does offer more confirmed upgrade instruments).

  6. Phone Agents Who Don’t Know Geography. No, these sweet agents aren’t necessarily losing their jobs due to redundancy. But assuming that Doug Parker does what he says — keeps the IT platform of the larger airline, a lesson whose importance he learned from combining US Airways and America West (and presumably from watching United’s debacle last year), we lose the combined wonderfulness of US Airways IT platform which (1) doesn’t auto-price, the agent locks in pricing manually, and (2) instant ticketing. American’s computers price awards, usually correctly (although not always), and even if there’s a mistake in your favor that doesn’t mean it’s a done deal because reservations get queued for ticketing where they’ll be reviewed for accuracy — including that you’re not being undercharged. That may be the end of the creative routings between Australia and the U.S. via South America and Europe for no extra miles, may she rest in peace.

  7. Cheap Australia awards. US Airways charges 110,000 miles for business class to Australia or 140,000 miles for first class. They allow you to route direct from the US, or to travel via Asia (and if an agent declines the routing, hang up and call back). It’s cheaper to fly to Asia and from Asia to Australia than just to fly to Asia, since South Asia roundtrips are 120,000 miles in business and 160,000 in first. Bangkok and Sydney is cheaper than just Bangkok, and Thai Airways has amazing availability to Sydney. American on the other hand wants 125,000 miles for a business class award — and does not permit Asia routings at all, except as part of distance-based oneworld awards which are pricier still.

  8. Free stopovers on roundtrip awards, and not just at the North American gateway city

  9. Routing through Asia to Australia for no additional miles and more generally none of the strange American AAdvantage rules that you cannot fly between region A and region B with a connection in a third region unless there are specific allowed exceptions (like flying between North America and Africa via Europe, or North America to South Asia via North Asia) and that you cannot fly between two cities on a single award if the most significant airline on the itinerary doesn’t publish a fare between those cities.

  10. 30,000 mile business class awards within ‘South and Central Asia’ (roundtrip). Awards between India and Indonesia or Maldives and Malaysia for 30,000 roundtrip in business class. American charges 45,000 miles roundtrip within ‘Asia 2′ — and 60,000 for roundtrips between ‘Asia 2′ and the ‘Indian Subcontinent’

And here’s my bonus #11:

  • Grand slam. That was probably my favorite promotion, it was downright fun, collect activities with thirty-someodd partners to net 100,000 miles, and it was a puzzle to see just how cheaply you could do it. (Plus it introduced me to Biscoff spread.) Sure Grand Slam didn’t run in 2012, but there’s been rumors about its return in 2013. The merger may put that on ice. But the specific promotion isn’t the point — US Airways Dividend Miles has probably been the most aggressive on the promotions front generally over the past 3 to 4 years, including outright mileage sales on the cheap. It’s that aggressiveness that may at least be tempered by the combination with American, a larger and more conservative program.

There’s plenty to love about the merger for the value of US Airways miles, but I started by pondering the things I’ll miss. Do you see your US Airways miles getting more or less valuable with the merger?

  1. A. S. said,

    I’ll miss the clueless agents the most, although they’re a double edged sword!

  2. Mason said,

    I’m going to miss business class to South Africa via South American and Europe for 110,000. Got that one booked for this summer. Sure looking forward to it. Too bad it won’t be repeatable.

  3. tassojunior said,

    If America-West/US is any indication don’t expect this merger to go very fast. AW and US pilots still are not allowed in the same cockpit.

    I expect the cheapness, the nickel-and-diming, of US and Parker to take over at AA pretty soon tho.

  4. Lee said,

    Gary,

    Do you think they’ll stop selling miles cheaply? I love using the 100% bonus sales, but am worried they will go away after the merger.

  5. Michael said,

    There is only one good thing I see about this merger. For a brief period of time we will probably be able to transfer miles between the two programs. Beyond that it’s gonna suck. In about a year from now AA will devalue its chart.
    Losing US AIR star alliance booking is a huge loss.

  6. Jim L said,

    I’ll miss being able to use my US Airways miles on the STAR alliance.

  7. db said,

    I am really scared the US “starnet blocking” will be implemented by Doug for the new AA.
    New CEO, quick way to make a small positive impact on P&L, we might see blocking of CX F for example…

  8. SL said,

    I like the clueless U.S. Airways agent. I booked a trip from U.S to BKK onto RGN on one segment of lst class and rest on biz for 120k instead of 160k.

  9. jack said,

    searching for oneworld awards is quite a pain … let’s see if AA would do anything to improve this (or is it done on purpose in order to reduce premium partner redemptions?)

  10. UAPhil said,

    Losing Star is painful….fortunately I have a good stash of UA miles. (But I won’t miss US Airways restrictive change policies.)

  11. Tom said,

    With delta likely to move to a revenue based program in 2014, do you think there is a risk that they also decide to launch a brand new rev based program for the new AA?

  12. stephan said,

    Might make LH/LX/SQ loosen up F availability once the “*A official miles consolidator” has left the building…

  13. Brian L. said,

    @stephan – I hope so too, but I don’t think it’ll happen.

  14. MnMar said,

    Gary,

    Do you by any chance know how far in the future will the US Airways miles become AAdvantage miles? Are we talking anytime before June 1 or later?

    Thanks!

  15. Gary said,

    Definitely after June 1

  16. Add A Comment

home | top

View from the Wing is a project of Miles and Points Consulting, LLC. This site is for entertainment purpose only. The owner of this site is not an investment advisor, financial planner, nor legal or tax professional and articles here are of an opinion and general nature and should not be relied upon for individual circumstances.

Advertiser Disclosure: Many (but not all) of the credit card offers on the site are from banks from which we receive compensation if you are approved. Compensation does not impact the placement of cards other than in banner advertising (we do not currently control the banner advertising on this blog). We don’t include all US credit card offers available on this site. Instead, I write primarily about cards which earn airline miles, hotel points, and some cash back (or have points that can be converted into the same).

Editorial Note: The opinions, analyses, and evaluations here are mine and not provided by any bank including (but not limited to) American Express, Chase, Citibank, US Bank, Barclaycard or any other company. They have not reviewed, approved or endorsed what I have to say.