One of the frequent controversies in the frequent flyer world is, should the mileage-earning opportunity be shared?

On the one hand, the community benefits by sharing with each other. Before internet forums and blogs a mistake fare might be discovered by one person, they would share with a few friends, but that would be it. In the modern age a mistake fare is discovered, it goes viral, and many more people either have their tickets cancelled or luck our and wind up with a once in a lifetime to travel the world at ridiculously low prices. (And what’s once in a lifetime for many turns out to be ‘just another Wednesday’ for many of us.)

The fear is that ‘too much exposure’ will lead to a deal being pulled more quickly than if it had been kept quiet. Fewer people benefit if deals are kept close to the vest, but those people benefit potentially for longer periods of time.

These are the debates that consume some gatherings of frequent flyers. But rarely do they consider that sharing a deal might have major political and national fiscal implications.

It turns out that sharing of one deal had just that effect.

Wall Street Journal reporter Scott McCartney emails me this afternoon to say that dollar coins, it turns out, are the inspiration for the current in vogue notion that the government should mint a trillion dollar platinum coin and deposit it at the Fed as a means of averting the debt ceiling crisis (so that the President doesn’t have to offer spending cuts to induce House Republicans to be willing to allow the federal government to borrow more money).

Here’s his blog post on the subject.

Scott learned about buying coins with a credit card to earn miles (with no shipping charges), depositing those coins in the bank to pay of the credit card, on a MegaDO frequent flyer trip. He wrote a piece on it, and the notion of buying commemorative coins and depositing them turns out to have been the inspiration for ‘depositing of a the $1 trillion Platinum coin’ debt ceiling idea.

This week Paul Krugman endorsed the idea, though I agree that the perverse consequences would outweigh any benefits.

This new Wired article goes into detail on how the Wall Street Journal piece that came out of the MegaDO launched the policy idea.

It was a December 2009 Wall Street Journal article that ultimately inspired the Georgia lawyer known online as “Beowulf” to invent the trillion-dollar coin.

The article, “Miles for Nothing,” detailed how clever travelers were buying commemorative coins from the U.S. Mint via credit cards that award frequent flier miles. The Mint would ship the coins for free and the travelers would deposit them at the bank, pay off their cards, and accumulate free miles.

More than six months later, during a wonky online discussion about the debt ceiling, Beowulf thought of the article and, egged on by fellow monetary-system obsessives, came up with his own clever plan to exploit the powers of the U.S. Mint. His idea to issue a single trillion-dollar coin to the U.S. Treasury, thus letting it avoid borrowing and bypass the debt ceiling, is now much discussed among Washington elites, including at the White House, where a spokesman Wednesday wouldn’t rule out the scheme.

I first wrote about buying coins from the U.S. Mint in June 2008. In the summer of 2009, the deal exploded as the Mint lifted the per-person cap on purchases.

Scott McCartney learned all about it on the first Star Mega DO and wrote a Wall Street Journal column about it. That was three years ago.

After attention in the press, the Mint took some heat for letting the practice continue. And they started to scold some people for doing it in some pretty extreme ways.  But the deal continued on, it wasn’t actually killed at that time.

By the summer of 2010, the mint placed a limit of $1000 in purchases every 10 days.  But, of course, people continue to purchase what they were willing to sell. Some credit card programs, like US Bank Flexperks, stopped awarding points for the purchases. And Chase closed down accounts from some very high volume purchasers. But on the whole, things were still chugging along fine, even a couple of years after the deal had gotten public scrutiny.

A year and a half ago, though NPR ran a story explaining that the deal was still alive and well. And the Mint continued to get a little too much spotlight for their comfort. And the deal finally died in the summer of 2011.

While the initial media attention didn’t kill the deal, arguably subsequent attention on NPR did, although it’s hard to suggest a deal that went on for years was ‘killed prematurely.’

What seems indisputable, though, is that the media attention led to a shift in the national discussion of government spending and debt.

So perhaps the lesson is that frequent flyers have substantial pull in policy debates, or perhaps that lobbyists who wish to change policy should be trying to get on one of our frequent flyer MegaDO trips like the one in November where we chartered United’s first 787 (which was covered in the New York Times, Wall Street Journal, and the Economist).

  1. Amol (@PointsToPointB) said,

    I just got a “no pre-set spending limit” American Express Platinum Card. Can I first buy the trillion dollar coin and then deposit it myself? And until 1/14, 1 trillion MR points becomes 1.3 trillion Avios.

    Or maybe I’ll use the Premier Rewards Gold, I’ll get another 15K MR for hitting $30K spend. Trillion Mile Secrets!

    Even a 2% cash back card would net me $20 billion.

  2. dan hammer53 said,

    Oh dear.

    Looks like the collective we (Flyertalkers and MegaDoers) killed the deal ourselves. It’s a regular Agathie Christie who done it.

  3. Gene said,

    Can I order a trillion coin from the Mint with my credit card? I’ll gladly paying the shipping. :)

  4. Matt said,

    @Gene – If your credit limit is that high, more power to you!

  5. Gene said,

    @Amol — I suggest using the cash back card.

  6. Mark (@palmerlaw) said,

    I think Amol (@PointsToPointB) just summarized @PointsEnvy entire next blog entry! Awesome!

  7. Amol (@PointsToPointB) said,

    @Gene – I agree, 1 trillion MR points transferred to Delta will only get me 5 BusinessElite seats to Johannesburg.

  8. MileageUpdate said,

    There’s already a better gig for Skypesos than the mint ever was.

  9. Delta Points said,

    @Mark @Amol @MU – I value my Skymiles at 5cpm ;-) I don’t know what all your issues are I always fine low level seats and perfect flights. Ah well….

  10. Gene said,

    @MileageUpdate — Are you referring to Vanilla Reloads + Bluebird, the electronic Mint?

    @Amol — ROFL!

  11. Robert Hanson said,

    If the US Treasury just has the Mint produce a hundred billion Trillion dollar coins, then the IRS can issue everyone a Billion dollar tax “refund”. Then since we will all be Billionaires, we can all quit our jobs, and just buy dozens of round the world FC tickets, and book thousands of Park Hyatt Suites, without even bothering about miles and points programs ever again. :D

    That this sort of thing conversation is actually going on in DC, and that people like Krugman can advocate it, and still call himself an “economist” is {take your pick} amazing, hilarious, pathetic, extremely frightening. Perhaps all of the above ?

  12. Thomas Sewell said,

    I hate to break it to these guys, but there’s nothgin new under the sun… The “mint a coin to pay the Fed” idea was popularized by Presidential Candidate Bo Gritz back in 1992. It was a huge part of his platform.

    From an old archive, so you can see the 1992 date: http://www.nizkor.org/ftp.py?people/g/gritz.bo/gritz.dat

    And, if this only
    costs a cent to make, but they have to give us 25 cents
    credit, what is wrong with minting a giant coin (Bo holds up
    a 5″ diameter, giant coin) that says “Four Trillion
    Dollars Debt of the United States Paid in Full In God We
    Trust.” (Huge round of applause.) Now, I ask you, let’s be
    very clear about it: is that legal? I’d be very
    enthusiastic if I thought I could get my great grandkids, my
    grandchild who’s thirteen now and my three mules and a
    daughter, if I could get them out of debt because they all
    owe $42,000. That’s what every one of you owe and that’s
    what your kids owe and if you’re born today, that’s the
    price of being an American. I’d be excited about thinking
    on this because is this coin going to be made out of gold?
    Is it going to be made out of silver? No, it has to be made
    out of pot metal because it has to be worthless! It has to
    equal what it is that they have been giving us all this
    time!

  13. Gary Steiger said,

    During the good old mint dollar coin days, a Mint rep told me that the Mint actually makes money minting dollar coins. The dollar we paid for them was less than the cost of making them. Of course, the Fed had to pay the banks that dollar when we returned the coins via those banks, but the Mint didn’t care about that – it wasn’t on THEIR books.

    So now the Fed has a large pile of dollar coins stored, ready for use. Seems to me that this is a good thing, which we helped happen. When (if)Congress gets the courage to switch from paper to coin dollars, thus saving a lot of tax money, the Fed will be ready.

  14. Add A Comment

home | top

View from the Wing is a project of Miles and Points Consulting, LLC. This site is for entertainment purpose only. The owner of this site is not an investment advisor, financial planner, nor legal or tax professional and articles here are of an opinion and general nature and should not be relied upon for individual circumstances.

Advertiser Disclosure: Many (but not all) of the credit card offers on the site are from banks from which we receive compensation if you are approved. Compensation does not impact the placement of cards other than in banner advertising (we do not currently control the banner advertising on this blog). We don’t include all US credit card offers available on this site. Instead, I write primarily about cards which earn airline miles, hotel points, and some cash back (or have points that can be converted into the same).

Editorial Note: The opinions, analyses, and evaluations here are mine and not provided by any bank including (but not limited to) American Express, Chase, Citibank, US Bank, Barclaycard or any other company. They have not reviewed, approved or endorsed what I have to say.